The method
Clarion ran a deep-research pass on the AEO/GEO literature in July 2026: five parallel search angles, 22 sources fetched, 104 candidate claims extracted from the statistics that circulate in this industry's sales decks and commentary. Twenty-five of those claims were tested against primary sources, not against the blog post repeating them.
Every verdict is re-checked each quarter, most recently in November 2026. Two rules govern the labels. A claim is marked refuted only when a source we can name contradicts it. A claim we cannot confirm is marked unproven. Half true means the figure is real and the inference usually drawn from it is not. Clarion checks what it asserts publicly about AI search against this record.
The real collapse - stated first, because it's not a myth
First, the one finding in this research that needed no adversarial rescue: people really are clicking less. Pew Research Center tracked actual browsing behavior, not survey self-report, across 900 U.S. adults and 68,879 real Google searches collected in March 2025, 12,593 of which showed an AI summary. A traditional result got clicked in just 8% of visits when an AI summary appeared, versus 15% when it didn't - roughly half the rate. Only 1% of AI-summary visits produced a click on a citation link inside the summary itself. And users ended the browsing session after 26% of search pages with an AI summary, versus 16% of pages without one.
Google said the study used a flawed method and a skewed set of queries, and that it had not seen significant drops in aggregate web traffic. It published no click-rate figures of its own. A randomized experiment published since points the same way as Pew. What follows is a set of more dramatic numbers that travel with it. Some are accurate and dated. Others are unproven.
The overlap figures
Five entries are one family, most of them Ahrefs data, on a single question: does ranking well in Google predict being cited by an AI engine? Each was re-checked against its source in November 2026. The verdicts below are current, and the changes are recorded in State of AI Search, Issue 1.
Re-checked November 2026. The figure is in its source. Ahrefs' study of the 1,000 pages ChatGPT cited most in September 2025 puts Wikipedia at 29.7% of those pages, in the same table as the 32.3% influenceable share used below. It is a dated snapshot: Wikipedia has appeared in far fewer ChatGPT answers during 2026.
Re-checked November 2026. The figure is printed in the Ahrefs overlap study (July 2025 data) and is one of the five values averaged to give the 12% below.
Re-checked November 2026. The figure is in the same Ahrefs study as the 12%. It counts cited pages that do not rank for the original prompt; the 12% counts cited pages in the top ten. The two describe different parts of one chart.
Re-checked November 2026. The wording matches a July 2025 Semrush statement that pages cited by ChatGPT search ranked 21st or lower almost 90% of the time for related queries. The study as a whole covered more than 500 marketing topics, and Semrush did not say how this figure was measured. Ahrefs measured something close in August 2025: 9.85% of the URLs ChatGPT's searches returned were in Google's top 20 for the same search. AirOps, counting cited pages against the prompt and its sub-queries in March 2026, found 55.8% in a top 20. The claim depends on a definition.
Re-checked November 2026. This was Ahrefs' finding in July 2025, from the top three citations in each of one million AI Overviews. In March 2026 Ahrefs counted about four million cited URLs across 863,000 results pages and got 38%. The two differ in method as well as date, because the first counted only the top three citations. Treat 76% as a July 2025 figure for the most visible citations.
The real number: Ahrefs' analysis of 15,000 long-tail prompts found roughly 12% overlap between what AI assistants cite and what appears in Google's top 10 organic results for the same prompt. That's real and worth acting on - ranking well in Google does not reliably predict being cited by an LLM - but it's a single vendor's methodology on one dataset, not independently triangulated across sources. Treat it as directionally reliable, not as a number precise enough to put in a client deck to the second decimal. One more caution from the re-check: the 12% is an unweighted average of five values, and one of them is Perplexity at 28.6%. The other four average 7.7%.
The GEO-boost claim
Re-checked November 2026. The sentence is in the abstract of the paper that founded the field: Princeton and Georgia Tech's GEO-bench, published at ACM SIGKDD 2024. It is a benchmark result for sources already placed in the engine's context. A July 2026 survey of 45 GEO studies found no technique with a stable, cross-platform causal effect on being found. Accurate as a lab result, unproven as a promise to a client.
The CTR multiplier
Re-checked November 2026. Both multipliers are Seer Interactive's, from 3,119 informational queries across 42 client organizations, published November 2025. Seer's April 2026 update showed click-through on AI Overview queries rising again. Ahrefs' comparison ends in December 2025, the month Seer's series bottomed, so it neither confirms nor contradicts the rebound. One agency's client set, since revised by the agency. Cite the Pew figures from the section above.
The consensus claim
No source we can find measures this, for or against, so it is unproven. In the July pass it failed verification on a 0–3 vote. This is a popular framing in AEO commentary, and it has genuine intuitive appeal: it would explain a lot if true. No claim about how unlinked brand mentions, trust signals, or E-E-A-T factor into what an LLM retrieves or trains on survived independent verification in this research. The honest position: authority-building is a plausible, reasonable strategic bet, supported indirectly by adjacent findings elsewhere in this research. It is not a proven mechanism, and shouldn't be asserted to a client as one.
The schema half-myth
This is the most important counter-hype finding in the whole research pass, precisely because it's a real, measured correlation that turned out not to mean what it looks like it means.
The correlation is real. 53% of AI-cited pages carry JSON-LD schema markup - nearly three times the rate found on non-cited pages. That's exactly the number most AEO consultants point to as proof schema "works," and as a correlation, it holds.
The causal claim doesn't. Ahrefs ran a matched before-and-after study: 1,885 pages that newly added schema between August 2025 and March 2026, measured against roughly 4,000 matched control pages that didn't. Result: no statistically meaningful citation uplift on any platform tested. Google AI Overview citations for the schema group actually declined slightly, by 4.6%. AI Mode showed a 2.4% gain and ChatGPT a 2.2% gain - both statistically indistinguishable from zero.
The likely explanation: schema correlates with other things that do drive citation - technical maturity, content structure, a site that was generally built with more care - without being the mechanism itself. Clarion still builds schema into every entity graph it ships, for reasons this register's companion piece, How AI Verifies You're Real, lays out in full: verifiable authority is its own goal, independent of whether it moves a citation count in isolation. What this finding kills is the pitch that says "add schema, watch citations rise." That specific causal story doesn't survive contact with the Ahrefs study.
What survived - for balance
A register like this can read as more cynical about the field than the research is. Many of the 25 claims tested in July held up, and three are worth naming here because they shape how Clarion frames the opportunity to clients.
Semantic relevance predicts citation better than brand authority. Cited pages show markedly higher similarity to the user's actual prompt and the model's internal sub-queries than non-cited competitors for the same query - the model is pattern-matching meaning, not rewarding domain reputation directly.
The addressable opportunity is real, but smaller than "be everywhere AI looks." Of ChatGPT's 1,000 most-cited pages, only about 32.3% are realistically influenceable by brand or content marketing at all. The rest belong to categories no content strategy touches - Wikipedia, brand homepages, app stores, reference sites, forums. That number, not a bigger one, is the honest anchor for what a content strategy can actually compete for.
Freshness matters, but not the same way on every platform. AI assistants overall cite content that averages roughly 26% fresher, by publication date, than what shows up in organic Google results (Ahrefs, July 2025). In that data the top three citations in Google's own AI Overviews were the oldest of any surface tested. A smaller Seer Interactive study that June found the reverse for AI Overviews, so that half is contested, and both predate the model now behind them. Ask which engine a freshness rule was measured on.
Close
Two honest caveats belong at the end of this, not buried in a footnote. A large share of the strongest citation-behavior findings above trace back to one vendor, Ahrefs, using one dataset methodology. Individually well-documented and uncontested elsewhere, but that's not multi-vendor triangulation - treat these percentages as directionally reliable, not as independently replicated science. And this is a fast-moving field. Ahrefs' own data shows the share of US ChatGPT answers citing Wikipedia falling about 80%, and Reddit about 88%, between March and September 2026. This register carries a publish date on purpose. Revisit it, don't assume it.
The point of building this page wasn't to score points off a marketing category. It was cheaper to ship than almost anything else on Clarion's list, because the raw material already existed in research the studio had already done for itself. The value isn't in any single verdict - it's in the standing habit: before a number goes into a deck, a page, or a conversation with a client, it gets checked against something like this first.
FAQ
It's a standing, dated record of AEO/GEO statistics that circulate widely in pitch decks and LinkedIn posts each checked against its original source and given a verdict. Clarion built it after running its own research pass and finding that several widely repeated numbers did not say what they were quoted as saying. The register exists so Clarion doesn't repeat those numbers by accident, and so anyone else can check a claim before repeating it themselves.
Clarion ran a deep-research pass in July 2026: five parallel search angles, 22 sources fetched, 104 candidate claims extracted from the current AEO/GEO commentary. Twenty-five of those claims went through adversarial three-vote verification against primary sources, not secondary summaries. Every verdict is re-checked each quarter, most recently in November 2026. Verified means the figure is in its primary source and measures what the claim says. Verified as dated means it was accurate when measured and should not be read as current. A claim is marked refuted only when a source contradicts it. A claim that cannot be confirmed is marked unproven.
The academic discipline is real - Princeton and Georgia Tech published GEO-bench at ACM SIGKDD 2024, a peer-reviewed benchmark for testing content strategies against LLM answer engines. What remains unproven outside the lab is the "up to 40%" figure everyone quotes from that same paper. The field is legitimate. That number isn't a safe one to repeat as settled.
No - it means schema markup alone, added in isolation, showed no measurable citation lift in Ahrefs' matched study of 1,885 pages. Schema still correlates with being cited, and Clarion still builds it on every engagement, because it makes a firm's claims checkable by machine. Why cited pages carry it more often is not established. The myth is treating schema as a lever you can pull by itself. It isn't one.
No - that part holds up better than almost anything else in this register. Pew Research tracked actual browsing behavior across nearly 69,000 real Google searches and found people click a traditional result in 8% of visits when an AI summary appears versus 15% when it doesn't, and end the browsing session after 26% of pages with an AI summary versus 16% of pages without. The larger multipliers that circulate alongside it (a 61% or 41% organic CTR drop) come from one agency's client data, which the agency has since revised. Cite Pew.
Yes. The underlying research explicitly notes this is a fast-moving field with real methodological volatility even within a single high-quality source, and recommends revisiting the baseline within six to twelve months rather than treating any of it as permanent. Clarion re-checks every verdict each quarter against its primary source, the page carries the date of the last re-check, and changes are recorded in that quarter's State of AI Search briefing.